Home » Books » Book Review: Cross My Heart And Hope To Spy By Ally Carter

Book Review: Cross My Heart And Hope To Spy By Ally Carter

Book Review: Cross My Heart And Hope To Spy By Ally Carter

Title: Cross My Heart and Hope To Spy
Author: Ally Carter
Genre: Young Adult, Spy
Publisher: Orchard Books
Publication Date: 2nd Oct 2007
Goodreads Summary: Cammie Morgan may have a genius IQ and attend the best school in the country, but as she starts the spring semester of her sophomore year there are a lot of things she doesn’t know. Like will her ex-boyfriend even remember she exists? And how much trouble did she really get in last semester? And, most of all, exactly why is her mother acting so strangely?

All Cammie wants is a nice, normal semester, but she’s about to learn her greatest lesson yet—that when you go to a school for spies, nothing is ever as it seems.

Book Review

WARNING: May contain spoilers for those who have not yet read I’d Tell You I Love You But Then I’d Have To Kill You.

It’s the start of a new semester at Gallagher Academy and Cammie is trying to start afresh. After the disaster at the end of I’d Tell You I Love You But Then I’d Have To Kill You when her non-spy boyfriend, Josh, attempted to ‘save’ her whilst she was in the middle of a cover operations test, she’s got to regain the trust of her teachers and her fellow classmates and try to stop thinking about Josh.

However, when she arrives back at school, she starts to notice some odd things. For one, an entire corridor of the school has been ‘locked’, something unheard of at Gallagher Academy given that every single student knows how to pick a lock anyway.

Cammie and her friends are determined to uncover the secret that the headmistress, also Cammie’s mother, is hiding and what plans are about to be unveiled in the new locked corridor. Cammie’s Josh drama from the previous semester convinced those in charge of spy training that although the girls have the highest IQs in the country, they don’t know a thing about boys and they’re going to do something about it.

I really loved I’d Tell You I Love You But Then I’d Have To Kill You (man, that is long) but it took me quite a long time to get into it so I wasn’t sure what to expect from Cross My Heart and Hope To Spy. I whizzed through this book in one sitting and I love that these books are so easy to fly through in a few hours. Book 2 in this series is definitely better than book 1 in my opinion. The pace is a lot faster and the plot was far more interesting with more twists and turns along the way, especially towards the end. I thought that this was going to a really predictable book, but actually, the ending turned out slightly different to what I had imagined which is a plus for a YA book.

As with book 1, these books aren’t really about the romance, but more about the spying and Cammie Morgan, the main character. Although the plot was far more interesting in this one, I still found that the best thing about this book was not the story line, but the character of Cammie.

In book 1, I didn’t think that we got to see much of Cammie’s love interest, Josh, at all and so I never really connected much with his character, but things are different in Cross My Heart and Hope To Spy. The main boy of interest is Zach and there just seemed to be so much more to him than Josh. I probably think this because Zach is much more my type – mysterious, intelligent, possible dark side, whereas Josh is just a bit of a marshmallow all round.

Zach and Cammie interact a lot more than Josh and Cammie did which makes it easier to visualise and root for their relationship. That said, I was never really sure if we were supposed to be rooting for Zach or not and I didn’t really decide how I felt about him until the very last page, but it was good that this book kept me on my toes.

Cammie hasn’t really changed all that much since book one, except that she is slightly less naive and clueless about life. This was definitely a plus because although we miss out on some comedy, her naivety was starting to grate on me by the end of book one. I like that Cammie is a character who doesn’t get completely absorbed by just one thing, usually boys, but has time to care about her family, her friends, her school work, and boys. I think Cammie’s character was stronger in book two and I hope that she continues to develop throughout the rest of the series.

Cross My Heart and Hope To Spy had a pretty similar format to I’d Tell You I Love You But Then I’d Have To Kill You, in fact, you didn’t really need to read the first book at all in order to understand this one as it’s pretty self explanatory and in my opinion, there are few references to the first book.

Personally, I thought that book two was far better than book one in terms of plot and character. I’m still not really sure what to expect from book three, given that books one and two could basically be two standalone novels. Either way, I’m really excited to read it because I absolutely loved Cross My Heart and Hope To Spy

Buy Cross My Heart and Hope to Spy:
Amazon | Book Depository

Check out my reviews of the other Ally Carter books:
I’d Tell You I Love You But Then I’d Have To Kill You
Don’t Judge a Girl by Her Cover
Only the Good Spy Young
Out of Sight Out of Time
United We Spy 

Uncommon Criminals
Perfect Scoundrels

Stay up to date with What’s Hot?
Bloglovin’ / Instagram / Facebook / Twitter / Pinterest



Laura is a culture and travel blogger based in London. She studied French at Oxford University and now studies Law in London. She’s an avid reader and traveller and loves to combine the two with literary travel. Find her tips and reviews on the best reads, eats and destinations on whatshotblog.com.

Find me on: Web | Twitter



  1. kimbacaffeinate
    27th February 2013 / 10:46 PM

    I have not read this series, but I am a sucker for tales that take place at academies or boarding schools. I am glad to here book two was better.

  2. Brandi Kosiner
    28th February 2013 / 5:55 PM

    Glad it was faster than the first, and gald you enjoyed it. I haven't read anything of Carters and have stayed away for some reason.
    Brandi @ Blkosiner’s Book Blog

  3. Hanako Himawari
    7th June 2013 / 4:48 AM

    I'm currently reading book 1 ! :))

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Looking for Something?