Book Review: The Apple Tart Of Hope by Sarah Moore Fitzgerald

The Apple Tart of Hope Summary

Fourteen-year-old Oscar Dunleavy is missing, presumed dead. His bike was found at sea, out past the end of the pier, and everyone in town seems to have accepted this as a teenage tragedy. But Oscar’s best friend Meg knows he isn’t dead. Oscar is an optimistic and kind boy who bakes the world’s best apple tarts; he would never kill himself, and Meg is going to prove it.

Through interwoven narratives, the reader learns what really happened to Oscar. Meg must confront the painful truth of Oscar’s past six months—and the possibility that he might really be gone. Surrounded by grief and confusion, she starts to put the pieces back together. This story of love and friendship reminds us to keep hope in our hearts.

For fans of The Thing About Jellyfish and kids who need a reminder that really, all you need is love.

The Apple Tart of Hope Review

Following the disappearance of Oscar Dunleavy, one of the most loved boys at school, Meg, his best friend, flys back to Ireland from New Zealand. Having been away from several months, Meg doesn’t understand what could’ve driven Oscar to ride his bike off the cliff.

Sensing that something isn’t quite right, Meg and Oscar’s younger brother Stevie set off to find out what really happened to Oscar and what led to his disappearance.

The Apple Tart of Hope is a beautifully sweet read that leaves you with a warm and fuzzy feeling inside. It’s a story of friendship, love and hope. Told from the alternating perspective of both Oscar and Meg, the pair reminisce about the six months after Meg’s parents dragged her off to New Zealand. I

t’s curious how much of a connection you can feel between the two characters even though the reader doesn’t see the pair together in the present-time and can only read each individual’s memories of the other.

Reading the thoughts and feelings of both Oscar and Meg gives the reader an immediate connection to both of them. They’re the sort of people that you wish you knew and were friends with in real life. Both of them seem like real people and the author seems to have captured the thoughts of both the teenage boy and girl perfectly in her characters.

I don’t think the ages of either characters is explicitly mentioned which means that the characters could be teenagers of any age really but that makes this story even better – it is both ageless and timeless.

This story and the writing is so simple and yet so beautiful. There are a few twists and turns in The Apple Tart of Hope but for the most part I just meandered my way through this story.

Whilst this film was a lovely read, it does also highlight the social pressure that teenagers are under at high school and how it can all go very wrong, very quickly. This story isn’t really what you’d call ‘predictable’, but it’s not particularly hard to guess what the outcome will be either.

This story isn’t about the ending, it’s about the journey. You learn the true meaning of friendship and how you should never give up hope because, as the book cover says, “there’s always a crumb left”.

I wish I could find out more about Oscar, Meg and their world, but one of the best things about this book is that it is so short and sweet. Nothing about this book is superfluous; each and every word is on point and hits you right in the middle of the chest.

If you’re a fan of Rainbow Rowell’s Eleanor & Park then I think you’d enjoy this tale as well. This book is an unexpected gem and I would absolutely recommend it to everyone, old or young, for it is a thoroughly heart-warming tale with a few life lessons thrown in too.

*Many thanks to Orion Children’s Books for providing me with a review copy. All opinions are my own. 

Find a copy of The Apple Tart of Hope on Amazon here

If you liked the sound of this book, you may also enjoy these titles:
House of Windows by Alexia Casale
The Perks of Being a Wallflower by Stephen Chbosky