Home ยป Review ยป Book Review: Lost In Time by Melissa De La Cruz

Book Review: Lost In Time by Melissa De La Cruz

Book Review: Lost in Time by Melissa de la Cruz (Blue Bloods)

Title: Lost in Time
Author: Melissa de la Cruz
Genre: YA, Paranormal, Romance
Publisher: Atom
Publication date: 27th September 2011
Goodreads Summary: The stakes have never been higher for the young Blue Bloods of Manhattan. After their brief yet beautiful bonding ceremony in Italy, Schuyler Van Alen and Jack Force depart for Egypt, desperate to find the elusive Gate of Promise before Jack must face his twin, Mimi, for a blood trial. A blood trial that only one of them can survive. But everything Schuyler thought she knew about the gate turns out to be a lie, and they soon find themselves ensnared in a deadly battle against the demon-born. Schuyler and Jack take up arms, only to realize that there is a much graver threat simmering in the Kingdom of the Dead.

Meanwhile, determined to save the only vampire she still loves, Mimi has followed Kingsley Martin into Hell. With the help of her new human Conduit, Oliver Hazard-Perry, Mimi makes a bargain with the Queen of the Dead that she may soon regret. When the time comes to choose between love and revenge, both Mimi and Oliver will learn the true meaning of sacrifice.

Confronted by danger, betrayal, and loss at every turn, the Blue Bloods must find the will to fight – and love – another day.

Book Review

WARNING: This review may contain spoilers for those of you who have not read the previous books. Check out my reviews of them here: Masquerade, Revelations, The Van Alen Legacy and Misguided Angel.

This series seems to alternate between awesome books and not so awesome books. So since Bloody Valentine, the Blue Bloods novella proceeding this book, was frickin’ awesome, that would make this book not so awesome.

There are three main plot threads in Lost in Time, one with Jack and Schuyler, one with Mimi, Oliver and Kingsley, and one with Allegra, Steven and Charles. The three plot strands are explored in alternate chapters  as it does in the other novels but it particularly bothered me in this one for some reason. I felt that the chapters were too short and I didn’t have enough time to get into them before we were thrust into another story. Sure, there was a cliff hanger on the end of all the chapters which kept you reading, but given the change of scenery and a few new concepts to get to grasps with, I was just confused.

Jack and Schuyler are in Egypt where they believe the real Gate of Promise is but of course there are still a hundred thousand obstacles between them and their goal. If I’m perfectly honest, I don’t remember Jack and Schuyler’s thread all that much despite the fact that I finished this novel just this morning.

At the beginning of this series, this pair was the thing I always most excited to read about, but as time has gone on, it has become my least favourite. The spark and excitement in reading about their relationship has completely died and their story just isn’t as interested as it used to be. This is probably because their story line is one that started right back in book one whereas some of the others are new and refreshing to read about.

The other thing that I’ve come to realise is that I believe Schuyler is actually younger than me and she’s already found a boy who she’s irrevocably in love with, who she’d die for, yada yada yada. It just seems a bit unrealistic to me. Not that any of the other young adult books I read are particularly realistic either, but this pair actually act like an old married couple, probably because they are actually married – which is also kind of creepy.

The other two plot strands are far more interesting. Mimi and Oliver have travelled to the Underworld to try and rescue Kingsley Martin, Mimi’s new love interest. The problem is that things are quite as they expected. After their long and perilous journey to find Kingsley, they find that he is not tortured or unhappy, but he seems to be pretty content and not all that bothered about Mimi’s appearance in the Underworld.

This section fluctuated between mediocre and really, really awesome. The bit that was really really awesome was a romantic scene between Kingsley and Mimi that actually made me cry (yes, real tears). My opinion of Mimi was shifting between love and hate constantly throughout this novel but in the end I decided that I love her character. She may seem really bitchy but deep down she has got a heart and she’s really loyal and even though sometimes her decisions make you want to hate her, she does do the right thing in the end.

The third plot strand in Lost in Time is a flashback from Allegra and Bendix’s (or Steven’s) past. It’s been several years since Allegra left him at Edicott Academy and she’s resigned herself to loving and bonding with her brother Charles (creepy, right?), but everything changes when she bumps into Bendix at an art gallery.

The story of Allegra’s past has consistently been my favourite part of this series and this was no exception. It’s really interesting to read about her past life as it makes some of the events in the present a little clearer, especially since lots of the older characters in the present are featured in Allegra’s past. This part of the story is also really romantic, though I would argue not quite as romantic as Mimi and Kingsley’s. This particular part of their history isn’t as exciting as it has been in past books but it’s really interesting nevertheless.

At the end of Lost in Time, two of the plot strands come together and there’s a pretty climatic finale. I’m excited to read Gates of Paradise, the last book in this series, and I’m really, really hoping that it’s good. Hopefully all the plot strands from the previous books will all come together in this book and be resolved but I’m trying not to get my hopes up just in case it’s a disappointment.

I feel like this series has been dragging on for so darn long,  I kind of just want it to end. Don’t get me wrong, some bits are brilliant, but the basic plot line hasn’t changed all the much and the same story has been carried through six (eight, if you include the novellas) and it still hasn’t been resolved. 

Lost in Time is definitely worth a read for the Mimi/Kingsley and Allegra/Bendix parts, but in my opinion, Jack and Schuyler’s part of the story is a massive let down.

Buy Lost in Time:
Amazon | Book Depository

If you liked this post, check my other Blue Bloods reviews:

The Van Alen Legacy
Keys to the Repository
Misguided Angel
Bloody Valentine (novella)
Gates of Paradise

Stay up to date with What’s Hot?

Bloglovin’ / Instagram / Facebook / Twitter / Pinterest



Laura is a culture and travel blogger based in London. She studied French at Oxford University and now studies Law in London. She’s an avid reader and traveller and loves to combine the two with literary travel. Find her tips and reviews on the best reads, eats and destinations on whatshotblog.com.

Find me on: Web | Twitter



  1. Sarah Elizabeth
    4th February 2013 / 4:54 PM

    I sometimes wonder if a series should really keep going on and on and on. the books often become totally different to how the series started, like anita blake vampire hunter, which seemed to turn in to anita blake vampire humper!

    • Laura Hartley
      10th February 2013 / 9:45 PM

      This comment made me laugh so hard!! I haven't read that series myself but it sounds interesting ๐Ÿ˜‰

  2. Brandi Kosiner
    4th February 2013 / 10:07 PM

    Aw, sorry it feels draggy. Maybe next will be awesome again and wrap it up.
    Happy reading,
    Brandi @ Blkosinerโ€™s Book Blog

    • Laura Hartley
      10th February 2013 / 9:49 PM

      I certainly hope so! I'll find out soon anyhow.. Thanks for stopping by! ๐Ÿ™‚

  3. Sel
    5th February 2013 / 3:40 PM

    Oh my God, yes yes yes! I was totally in love with Jack and Schuyler's relationship in book 1 and I was just rooting for them to get together. But, after the Van Alen Legacy, my passion for them just died down :/ Their journey together was pretty much the same thing over and over again and it was boring. But Mimi and Kingsley made up for that ๐Ÿ™‚

    Love your review! I couldn't have said it better myself ๐Ÿ˜‰

    • Laura Hartley
      10th February 2013 / 9:45 PM

      Finally someone who's read this series and understands how I feel!!! Mimi and Kingsley are so awesomeeee. I'm waiting for the last book in the series to arrive, I hope it's a good ending! ๐Ÿ™‚

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Looking for Something?